A Democrat challenger’s paid recount of the Jefferson County Commission District 3 race moved the margin by one vote on Thursday, and Republican Commission President Jimmie Stephens will serve a fifth term on the governing body of Alabama’s most populous county.
Stephens said three votes changed out of 51,263 recounted. Two went to Democrat Camara Blue, the pastor of Old Sardis Baptist Church in Birmingham. One went to Stephens. Blue called to concede shortly after the count ended, according to Stephens.
“Of the 51,263 votes cast in this election, today’s recount resulted in a net change of just one vote,” Stephens said in a statement. “Only three votes changed during the recount, with two additional votes for Mr. Blue and one for me. The final tally stands at 26,142 votes for me and 25,121 votes for Mr. Blue. Mr. Blue elected to waive the recount of provisional and absentee ballots.”
“That remarkable level of accuracy speaks volumes about the integrity of our election system and the professionalism of those entrusted with carrying it out,” he said.
Blue questioned the count two days after the November 3 election, when unofficial returns showed him trailing by 593 votes.
“I just know in this case, the numbers don’t make sense,” Blue said at the time.
Results certified last week gave Stephens 26,609 votes, or 50.33%, to Blue’s 26,217, or 49.59%. The 392-vote margin fell outside the 0.5% threshold for an automatic recount, which under Alabama law left Blue to pay for one himself. Jefferson County put the cost at $46,239.72. Blue told WVTM 13 the bill rose to $52,000 when he went to pay it.
“I feel like I’m being bullied,” Blue told the station on the eve of the recount. He accused Stephens of influencing the recount’s rules and staffing.
Stephens answered in a written statement to the station: “There has never been an election margin this large overturned.”
On Thursday, Stephens said he never doubted the result.
“Mr. Blue exercised his legal right to request and pay for this recount, and I certainly do not begrudge him for doing so,” Stephens said. “Shortly after the recount concluded, Mr. Blue called to congratulate me and concede the election. I appreciated his call and the graciousness he demonstrated. He ran a good campaign, and I wished him well in his future endeavors.”
Republicans went into the election holding three of the commission’s five seats. The district lines are the subject of a federal lawsuit. U.S. District Judge Madeline Haikala struck down the county’s 2021 map last year, and the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals kept that map in place for 2026 while the county appeals.
RELATED: Obama-appointed judge orders Jefferson County to add additional black-majority district
“The election is over, the people have spoken, and I am honored to continue serving,” Stephens said. “Now, let’s move Jefferson County forward — together.”
Grayson Everett is the editor in chief of Yellowhammer News. You can follow him on X @Grayson270.

