Tide Takes: Alabama lucky to avoid Vanderbilt disaster following QB mess

Alabama Football/X

The Alabama Crimson Tide left Nashville with a different result this time around than two years ago, defeating Vanderbilt 21-6 on an afternoon where the offense looked to be missing a gear.

All week long, the question was being asked whether or not Keelon Russell would play following an ankle injury he suffered last week against LSU, but when he was listed as probable on the injury report Wednesday night, it seemed to be put to bed.

By Friday afternoon though, it was being reported he was a game-time decision and backup Austin Mack had taken a bulk of the first team reps during practice that week. By Friday night, reports were that Mack would start the game and Russell would be on the bench.

RELATED: Keelon Russell will be game-time decision vs. Vanderbilt with ankle injury

That did not change until the start of the broadcast when the SEC Network commentators revealed Russell would actually be getting the nod following pregame warmups.

It was a true game-time decision, and after a week of not taking any real reps at practice, Russell looked extremely rusty. What he did not look like, however, was limited in his mobility due to the ankle. While it’s understandable they wanted to let him heal, it was obvious he could have done more at practice during the week than they allowed.

Kalen DeBoer mismanaged the situation at quarterback, giving Mack all of the work throughout the week and being too cautious with Russell, only to let Russell start the game while clearly not being prepared enough to start the game.

Ultimately, Russell’s talent weighed out and Alabama was able to win the game largely because of some of the plays he made on offense, but it’s worth wondering whether or not starting Mack after the decisions made throughout the week would have been the better way to go about things.

These decisions are never easy, especially with everything still ahead of Alabama. All that to say, DeBoer did not make the right calls during practice throughout the week, and in turn, did not make the right call on Saturday. If Russell was going to play — which he should have been as the starter if he was able — he needed to get more practice reps in than he did.

Regardless, the performance from the defense was strong enough that it allowed the offense to figure things out slowly, but the Crimson Tide should consider itself lucky that some questionable decision making from the coaching staff did not cost them this game and in turn, the season.

Michael Brauner is a Senior Sports Analyst and Contributing Writer for Yellowhammer News. You can follow him on Twitter @MBraunerWNSP and hear him every weekday morning from 6 to 9 a.m. on “The Opening Kickoff” on WNSP-FM 105.5, available free online.