A Montgomery resident and former employee of the Alabama Medicaid Agency has pleaded guilty to aggravated theft of property in Montgomery County Circuit Court.

According to Attorney General Steve Marshall, Natalie Colette Lewis, 60, stole over $100,000 in public funds and now faces up to 30 years imprisonment, a $60,000 fine, and forfeiture of her state retirement benefits.

The Attorney General’s Medicaid Fraud Control Unit investigated the case after the Medicaid Agency discovered the theft.

“Public service is a responsibility, not a personal financial opportunity. When employees violate that duty for personal gain, it is a direct assault on the taxpayers of Alabama,” stated Marshall. “We will continue to hold anyone accountable who defrauds the system, exploits taxpayer resources, or undermines the integrity of public trust.”

Lewis, who used the money for personal expenditures, had three prior felony convictions when she went to work for the Agency, after lying on her state application for employment by stating that she had no prior convictions.

Per the AG’s office, she received a restoration of rights pardon in 2017 for those convictions.

Lewis had been employed as a Medical Care Benefits Specialist, assigned to the Medicaid Agency’s Non-Emergency Transportation Division, since 2006.

While employed at the Agency, she was responsible for processing claims to reimburse Medicaid recipients for expenses incurred for their travel to medical visits.

From December 2019 to November 2024, Lewis entered 1,631 claims for transportation expenses on behalf of her son, a Medicaid recipient, for medical appointments that never took place.

In total, Lewis received $103,413.26 for the fraudulent claims.

The case is being prosecuted by Assistant Attorney General Nathan Mays. Sentencing is set for October 2nd.

Austen Shipley is the News Director for Yellowhammer News. You can follow him on X @ShipleyAusten