The appointment of Michael Pickett as the new Chief of the Birmingham Police Department has sparked mixed reactions among community leaders and residents. Mayor Randall Woodfin announced Pickett’s appointment on April 1, following his interim tenure that began November 29, 2024, when former Chief Scott Thurmond retired.
Alabama State Representative and Birmingham mayoral candidate Juandalynn Givan expressed strong opposition to Pickett’s appointment. According to ABC33/40, Givan questioned Pickett’s qualifications, emphasizing that aside from his recent roles as deputy chief and interim chief, he lacks significant supervisory experience in law enforcement.
RELATED: Birmingham Crime Commission releases report calling for action to reverse city’s deadly trajectory
She criticized the decision, asserting that the appointment reflects ongoing issues within the police department, suggesting that political connections played a role rather than merit and experience. Givan also pointed out that Birmingham, which has seen nearly 1,000 violent deaths over the past seven years, is critically understaffed with fewer than 400 sworn officers—far short of the minimum 1,300 needed for a city of its size. She additionally stressed that fair and transparent hiring practices are crucial for ensuring public safety.
In contrast, some community members have welcomed Pickett’s leadership. WBRC reported that Devonta Ravizee, a local activist from the East Lake community, expressed optimism about Pickett’s appointment. Ravizee highlighted that Pickett’s local roots and understanding of Birmingham’s neighborhoods could help build stronger connections between the police force and the community.
Ravizee, who grew up facing challenges related to gang culture and violence, has since become an advocate for positive change in the city. He believes Pickett’s firsthand experience in Birmingham makes him relatable to the community and could foster trust between law enforcement and residents. Furthermore, WBRC reported that city leaders credit the new chief’s crime reduction strategies with a nearly 50% decrease in the city’s homicide rate.
As the city moves forward, voices on both sides continue to share their perspectives. Givan has called for a more merit-based approach to leadership appointments, emphasizing that public safety should be the central priority. Meanwhile, supporters like Ravizee remain hopeful that Pickett’s personal connection to Birmingham will pave the way for more effective community policing and crime reduction.
Sherri Blevins is a writer for Mountain Valley News and a staff writer for Yellowhammer News. You may contact her at [email protected].
