Billionaire Duff brothers, ex-wildlife commissioner Billy Deviney named in Mississippi deer pen violations report

Mississippi Duff Brothers
(Texas A&M University, Southern Tire Mart, YHN)

An inspection report from the Mississippi Department of Wildlife, Fisheries and Parks alleges violations at 10 of the 12 deer breeding pens it inspected, SuperTalk Mississippi reported.

Two of the pens are owned by billionaire brothers Tommy and Jim Duff and another by former state wildlife commissioner Billy Deviney. There are potential state law infractions including deer dying without being reported, deer not being accounted for, and improper breeding practices.

Inspectors documented 13 deer that died without samples submitted for chronic wasting disease, a fatal and highly contagious disease among white-tailed deer that can persist in the environment. At least 53 deer were untagged, carried faded tags or bore tags from other enclosures, and more than 160 had incorrect, missing or untraceable records.

RELATED: Who owns Alabama’s deer? Lawmakers, conservation officials clash over proposed bill

The property which belonged to the Duff brothers, who built Southern Tire Mart into an empire, was inspected on April 23, 2026 and its status was listed as “Administrative Quarantine.” The report showed no harvest data for the 2025-26 season, five deer that died in the breeding pens with three not submitted for CWD sampling, three untagged deer and 19 deer with incorrect records.

The most significant issue with the Duff pen was left out of the report first released to the requester. A tip later revealed the pen had been placed under administrative quarantine after the discovery of unpermitted semen importation. SuperTalk reported the department now says the deficiencies are corrected and the quarantine lifted, with citations issued or coming.

The Deviney enclosure had similar issues, with the report there stating “three deer died in a breeding pen/after release into a larger enclosure and did not get submitted for CWD sampling. 9 deer couldn’t be accounted for due to tags fading. 2 untagged mature bucks in the breeding pens with no evidence a tag was ever present. 2 untagged fawns in alleyway of breeding facility.”

The report also listed 12 deer with no previous records and 97 deer unaccounted for. SuperTalk reported that MDWFP later disputed the 97 figure as inaccurate.

Lann Wilf, a wildlife consultant, former head of MDWFP’s deer program and host of the YouTube channel Old Biologist, pointed out the inconsistencies in the reports to SuperTalk.

“Why did SE48 (Duff Enclosure) have an administrative quarantine with the 19 incorrect records, three dead breeding pen deer with no samples, and three untagged deer, while SW01 (Deviney) had 97 discrepancies, 12 with no records, 14 vanished, two fawns of unknown origin, two bucks of unknown origin, and three CWD samples unaccounted for and no quarantine?” Wilf asked. “This makes no sense and is not logical. Quarantine is a big deal. Something has to be amiss.”

Wilf also added during his tenure with the MDWFP that he witnessed “multiple instances where individuals connected politically or who are wealthy received inconsistent enforcement of the law related to enclosure regulations, deer escapes from enclosures, and reproductive material importation. These inconsistencies are a significant part of why I changed employment in 2015.”

MDWFP officials did not comment specifically on the points from Wilf, but did state they are looking into it.

“I respect that former employees may hold their own views. I cannot speak about Mr. Wilf’s personal opinions as he left the employ of the agency over a decade ago, prior to my becoming executive director,” MDWFP executive director Lynn Posey said.

“Facility inspections are handled on a case-by-case basis. Every inspection is shaped by the facts at the time: current rules and guidelines, what staff observed, which requirements applied, and whether a deficiency was corrected.”

“They are playing Russian Roulette with our natural resource,” Wilf told SuperTalk.

Michael Brauner is a Senior Sports Analyst and Contributing Writer for Yellowhammer News. You can follow him on Twitter @MBraunerWNSP and hear him every weekday morning from 6 to 9 a.m. on “The Opening Kickoff” on WNSP-FM 105.5, available free online.